What Underlies the True Principle of "Orchestration" of Hameroff and Penrose

From noise in a massive number of tubulins...we get the coffee event, flows, stirring, etc....If I were to go back to the Orchestra....The conductor arrives on the scene and the musicians begin playing every 25 milliseconds, their own particular note: a D, a G, an A, a C, ...they just play that note or some note of their choice, simultaneously, every 25 milliseconds. There's no particular structure involved. The question is how do we get to structures of events specifying that coffee stirring?

 1 hr 10 mn into Dr. Stephen E. Robbin's discussion of Hameroff and Penrose

This is a very fascinating critique of Hameroff and Penrose! I had asked Dr. Robbins to read my previous commentaries on his Bergson videos.

So what I want to say is kind of difficult to convey - the first thing is to realize that Hameroff does not use music as just a metaphor - but rather Hameroff says he doesn't really understand why consciousness is more like music, although this is what he thinks.

And so I just want to point out that my own specialization is in music training and music theory and music-math connections, music perception, etc.

So Dr. Robbins makes an excellent critique of Hameroff's slide presentation.

He shows an image of the "Bing" of consciousness as the collapase - as a vertical drop - that as Dr. Robbins notes presents a kind of Zen K'oan - is there "zero time" as this vertical drop of the collapse of consciousness? Because that is what the slide shows yet if there is zero time as an instant of space for the collapse of consciousness, then how can there be a flow of time as consciousness?

So this is where things get difficult. Hameroff has stated that this origin of proto-consciousness of the universe is a "non-commutative scalar" field but he defers to Penrose for the details. If you study Penrose, as I focused on in my last blog post, in fact Penrose does emphasize "asymmetric time" as the key factor. Hameroff, in turn, states that the resonance is not Western harmonics (as we think of frequency) but rather "anharmonic" resonance.

I actually corresponded with Hameroff and his colleague who did the actual research on the microtubules using nanotechnology - in Japan - whom Dr. Robbins refers to in the video. So as he replied to me: Anirban Bandyopadhyay - that in fact we are talking about Bloch Spheres as different scales of resonance but we can never know the original phase of the Bloch Sphere of the Universe.

This is what Roger Penrose says is the cause of the Big Bang - asymmetric time as a phase shift.

And so then we get to the issue of continuity of time as Dr. Robbins details - does this occur with this "collapse" of consciousness every 25 milliseconds?

So Dr. Hameroff points out that for say people who meditate a lot, professionally, like Tibetan monks tested, their gamma frequency is much higher and stronger amplitude - and so this gamma frequency EEG is actually a "beat" frequency of the higher frequencies of quantum synchronization.

In contrast the science has shown that psychedelics that bind to the serotonin receptors - like DMT, LSD, etc. actually lower the blood levels in the brain to a lower frequency - and yet people experience consciousness as visuals - it's just a different form of consciousness, not as easily controlled by the ego.

So Dr. Robbins is considering the 25 milliseconds as the "reconstruction beam" of holographic consciousness - and yet how can it "bind" all the senses fast enough to create a seamless flow of time.

We know that the brain is very smart in creating illusions - like the "blind spot" in the mirror that our mind will "fill in" - when looking in a car mirror.

But we also know that in altered states of consciousness - like with meditation or psychedelics - the "reconstruction beam" as the prefrontal inhibition of subconscious perception - is shut off or controlled in different manners.

So this raises the question still - what enables the continuous flow of time and what "orchestrates" it holographically as the "hard problem" of consciousness?

For example a friend of mine had done a double dose of DMT-based plant "medicine" and he could see light within my body. Now a person might doubt this ability - and yet this is what the spiritual master healers can also do - see light and energy blockages inside other people's bodies.

We know from quantum biology that our body-mind is guided by biophotons as laser holographic energy-information and there is current research that has tested these biophotons emitted from microtubules and from neurons, activated by sound energy, that transduces into electromagnetic energy, along with application of neurotransmitters.

So my friend told me that he is trying to see where the light comes from! I said to him - that's the whole point you can't see where the light comes from!

What did I really mean? You can LISTEN to the Emptiness (as it's called in meditation) or rather you can "listen" to pure consciousness as time, but you can't SEE consciousness.

So going back to the music orchestration "metaphor" we have to accept that it is not just a metaphor! For example, as the discussion of Dr. Hameroff by Dr. Robbins goes into, if we have anesthesia then we lose consciousness - but as Dr. Robbins points out this consciousness lost is actually the "reconstructive beam" as the prefrontal inhibition awareness consciousness.

What should be noted though is that the last perception that is "lost" - in fact is maintained under anesthesia and this is subconscious auditory perception - at the theta hertz level.

So Dr. Robbins discusses a "frequency hierarchy" based on Dr. Hameroff's claim that the "deeper you go" into the microtubules as consciousness then the "higher you go" in terms of frequency energy.

But first of all it's well known in science that there is Fourier Uncertainty - meaning a trade off between time and frequency - the shorter the time pulse measured, the broader the energy bandwidth with less precision in location of the exact frequency - you get apparent noise or fuzzy energy frequency.

This, though, is the classical science "trade-off" still based on symmetric math. In terms of quantum physics though actually Heisenberg Uncertainty is from this inherent time-frequency trade off due to the transition from an infinite probability of phase - to the "measurement problem" as the "collapse" of consciousness.

And so there are 25 different "interpretations" of quantum physics - Dr. Robbins mentions some of the main ones - but what needs to be realized is that in fact this uncertainty arises from the more foundational "non-commutative time-frequency" resonance.

So in fact this is a more recent realization by Roger Penrose! He was advised by a fellow mathematician, that his Twistor model needed to be based on "noncommutative" or "non-commutative" resonance - aka asymmetric time is really the foundation of his proto-consciousness Universe. So Penrose now calls this the "palatial Twistor" model to emphasize his new discovery of non-commutative time-frequency energy as the foundation of reality.

Now then - back to the music metaphor - scientists - most scientists assume a Western music model for their "metaphor." But Dr. Hameroff, with his Indian colleague, has emphasized actually the music is nonwestern and it's not just a model or metaphor. It truly is based on "anharmonic" resonance. For example other scientists try to claim a symmetric math music model of reality - and I have contacted some saying - no in fact the empirical truth of music is noncommutative time-frequency resonance.

And so if music is not just a metaphor and it is non-commutative then how does it fit into the actual "reconstructive beam" of consciousness in the brain? I mentioned already that subconscious auditory perception is maintained even under anesthesia. So what Dr. Andrija Puharich argued is that the ELF brain waves - the theta-alpha brain waves are actually resonance of the proton-electron magnetic moment or precession spin. Dr. Puharich argued that this is the key secret of the memory storage and it is increased via Schumann Resonance of the Earth. Dr. Michael Persinger has confirmed this claim by Puharich. I corresponded with Dr. Persinger who responded that Puharich's research was "greatly under-appreciated."

And so the model of Hameroff, as Dr. Robbins rightly points out, needs to incorporate this non-commutative music resonance model that goes into subharmonics and overtones - at the same time! This is the secret of non-commutative phase.

So in quantum biology it is argued then that the quantum non-commutative phase is from these delocalized protons - and they are "split" from an increased electromagnetic energy to the water binding with the collagen of the microtubules. This emits biophotons and the light then has virtual photons that stores the information.

I have taken this dynamic and applied it to de Broglie's pilot wave model, that Puharich also relied on. So then we can think of human consciousness as based on light holographically - and yet the source of the biophoton laser holograph light is from reverse time or reverse entropy - what's called Yuan Qi energy or Prana in nonwestern science.

But Dr. Hameroff gets into this as well - in his paper on free will and precognition. So for example Michael Jordan when he goes into the "zone" and he sees the other players moving in slow motion - this really is precognition! How does it work? He has, through his extreme sports, increased his qi or prana energy from increased piezoelectric resonance of the collagen of the microtubules - 90% of the collagen as microtubules are vertically aligned.

So think of basketball as trance dance training! Jordan is sublimating his neurohormones - especially adrenaline which then has positive feedback with his pineal gland - and then via parasympathetic rebound (no pun intended!) increases the serotonin energy of the brain. Suddenly he has created a natural psychedelic "zone."

O.K. so the question still remains - is there "zero" time as a spatial instant and if so how can there be continuous time as flow of consciousness? There is "zero" time when the reconstruction beam goes away - in the ignorance of deep sleep - but this is also when melatonin is peaked and melatonin is the strongest anti-oxidant of the body-mind.

So the biophotons are emitted by the mitochondria working with the microtubules -as free radicals of oxygen use - and this is waking consciousness. If we can do the trance dance training as increased lower frequency theta-alpha brain waves from increased piezoelectric resonance of the collagen microtubules - then we also increase the serotonin levels for increased melatonin levels that heal the free radical damage to the mitochondria.

I go into these training details in my free pdf - the Idiot's guide to taoist alchemy neidan qigong neigong  yoga, etc.

O.K. so in terms of the music model we need to realize that in fact music perception bypasses Fourier time-frequency uncertainty by 10 times! And the mechanism for this to occur is the difference between the right and left ear as stereophonic hearing. As the quantum biologist Dr. Mae-Wan Ho pointed out - this phase synchronization of stereophonic hearing is in the microseconds level and so enables quantum phase synchronization based on ultrasound frequency.

And sure enough it is exactly ultrasound frequency that has the strongest amplitude of the microtubule resonance - 3000 times stronger electromagnetic transduction energy than other frequencies! This is also what Dr. Andrija Puharich discovered as well - it is the ultrasound, as a piezoelectric transduction of the collagen microtubules, that also creates a splitting of water via the vagus nerve increased energy to the neurotransmitters.

And so when Fourier Uncertainty is bypassed by hearing or listening - professional musicians do much better, indicating that training does help, but we are talking then about pulses of time - very fast and so what happens to the frequency? This is the fascinating result: When listening bypasses Fourier Uncertainty, the auditory perception shifts from the "home tone" frequency to a phase shift of the Perfect Fifth that does not change! (in contrast to classical Fourier Uncertainty that predicts a broadband fuzzy spread of frequency).

This is the secret of OM as noncommutative time-frequency resonance. So with strong psychedelic DMT plant medicine, as I experienced, you get a very strong vagus nerve energy to the right side of the heart, via sublimation of serotonin from the lower body, again through the right-side vagus nerve, that opens up the pineal gland as the heart-holographic astral biophoton energy. This is heard as a spontaneous loud OM sound emanating from the heart.

And so with this splitting of water there is then a superconducting proton-proton energy or proticity that is in fact superluminal! It is reverse time or reverse entropy energy as Yuan Qi - it is the relativistic energy of the photon - the virtual photons - that can be captured, as experiments have shown, as long as the process or dynamic occurs faster than Fourier Uncertainty! And so this proves that internal listening as meditation in fact can listen to the Emptiness of the proto-consciousness of the Universe.

Now Dr. Hameroff does state that our memories are then embedded in these micro black holes of the Universe - essentially - and so even though our "reconstructive beam" or even our dream state biophoton spirit consciousness will dissipate (or go into reincarnation) - it is this quantum memory via the non-commutative entanglement that is the flow of time as an eternal memory storage. I cite Dr. Jack Tuszynski, quantum biologist professor in Canada, on this long-term memory storage, despite physical destruction of the body! Memories are stored in the noncommutative time-frequency virtual micro black holes as the foundation of reality. This is how quantum masters or spiritual N/om healers of the original human culture can re-experience memories of another person or memories of another place. This happened to the cable t.v. host of Bizarre World, Andrew Zimmern. It happened through his heart energy being activated holographically - as a deep emotional cleansing as well so he burst out crying on t.v.

Just as memories change when they are "reconstructed" by each human, depending on the context - and just as precognition is real in this model - then we have to admit that in actuality this 5th dimension of noncommutative phase is the truth of reality.

As Paul S. Wesson emphasized in his analysis of de Broglie's pilot wave model, in fact all our perceptions and all matter-energy is happening all at the same time at the speed of light. But since the light itself has a "point" at that present moment, the light also has an entangled 5th dimensional energy from its relativistic momentum or pilot wave from the future that guides the light. This reverse entropy energy is the hidden momentum of light as the Yuan Qi energy-consciousness or the "proto-consciousness" and it is eternal formless motion that can not be seen. So as cosmologist Neil Turok emphasizes, the energy of the Universe is all equivalent based on time-frequency analysis. Something really big in the Universe lasting a long time has the same overall energy as something very tiny and very fast - this again is due to noncommutative phase of the inherent quantum foundation.

And so how does noncommutative phase "orchestrate" and by what principles? Noncommutative time-frequency is not random at all but rather based on the simple principle of 2, 3, (Perfect Fifth) infinity - as math professor Alain Connes points out and as Taoism and the "three gunas" of India and true Pythagorean harmonics points out. Roger Penrose has admitted that the greatest mystery of the universe - that plagues science - is "asymmetric time" and this is the key secret of why the Big Bang happened and will happen again. Of course the truth that all of modern science has ignored, this music empirical reality of asymmetric time, is a reflection of a deeper dynamic that goes beyond just science - into the philosophy of science and science policy, and deeper spiritual issues, etc.

There is no real "zero" time in this model - even though it appears that time goes to zero when we are in deep sleep or at apparent death, etc.  The typical quantum model assumes a probabilistic Hilbert Space but in contrast say the Bohm model that Professor B.J. Hiley expanded, bypasses Hilbert space, but using just non-commutative algebra. Similarly Penrose now uses non-commutative algebra and, he used to discuss his model with B.J. Hiley in detail - it was Hiley who came up with the Twistor spelling (as "or" not "er").

And so I agree with Dr. Robbins that the research of Penrose with Hameroff is building into AI research. And yet this AI research assumes there still is some proto-consciousness that is a kind of etheric medium that can be resonated with but not known originally.

What I would just emphasize is that math is left-brain dominant while music as listening is right brain dominant. In meditation the "focus" is to empty out the conceptual left brain of thinking by focusing on one thought as concentration. It is now proven that music training at early age then increases language acquisition and language comprehension because it is the timing of music that is left-brain dominant, helping with precision of timing of language.

And so linguist social scientist Noam Chomsky, for example, turns to the Henry Stapp quantum consciousness model, that has been critiqued by Jack Sarfatti who has developed a version of the Bohm model based on a back reaction quantum holographic reality. But Chomsky emphasizes that arithmetic is different than other symbolic math, as all humans have an innate sense of arithmetic. Studies have shown that arithmetic processing is done in the same part of the brain that maintains self-awareness - the parietal lobe. But it was Pythagoras who taught that "all is number and harmony" which really means, a great secret that was covered up by the wrong music theory, that in fact reality is from asymmetric time or noncommutative time-frequency energy resonance.

So Dr. Michael Persinger has shown how the right brain is biased in proto-consciousness activation as biophoton emissions - even after death! What we know then is that the right side vagus nerve connects to the left side of the brain but not vice versa! So the lower body neurohormone energy is sublimated up to the brain via the right side vagus nerve activated cerebrospinal fluid and blood and the increased piezoelectric transduction from the theta-alpha brain waves - from trance dancing or Tai Chi, basketball (Michael Jordan), etc. And so music listening is also right brain dominant but the vagus nerve connection to the cerebellum controls motion and emotion of the body-mind connection.

And so even though the prefrontal cortex is what defines modern humans as having the greatest "nodal" self-organizing phase synchronization of the rest of the brain - in fact, as Dr. Persinger has shown, it is the theta brain waves of the deeper cerebrum connected to the heart via the vagus nerve that provides the basis for the holographic biophoton organization of consciousness. As it is said in quantum chaos biology, as Dr. Brian Goodwin stated, "the subharmonics of the frequency show significant increase in amplitude."

So the left brain on its own is quite weak whereas modern science depends on right-hand technology to "apply" the mathematics, such that the measurement problem itself inherently exposes the Zeno Paradox of measuring time as space! So you can still have quaternions as noncommutative space - and yet this does not include noncommutative time. It was Tesla who first realized that resonating the Schumann Resonance enabled a free energy on earth - and yet he did all his science as right-brain dominant visions in time, seeing the machines moving backwards and forwards in time, etc. But Tesla had partially blamed himself for witnessing his brothers death, at a young age, outside in Nature, and so had a deep emotional spiritual awakening that gave him his holographic spirit gift.

So Tesla understood the ether as longitudinal pressure waves at the speed of light - this has been verified as the reverse entropy "phonon" phase momentum energy in quantum physics. Several of the main quantum physics models, especially the "transactional" model, rely on this "retrocausal" or back reaction view of reality. The question is, as Dr. Ruth E. Kastner, emphasizes is that this retrocausal volition as a Quantum Mind, is sub-empirical and so an intuitive given process before the actual "collapse" or "measurement" of left-brain dominance takes place.

For example Professor B.J. Hiley states that when time is zero there is already quantum entanglement but it is a novel "self force" as consciousness-energy. So in fact there is no "zero time" but this is assumed to then convert the self-force into eigenstates as spatial parameters for the "measurement" problem or "collapse." Hiley wants to use a more Western model of music to explain this consciousness - whereby the music score, written down, has the future already guiding the time-frequency. Alain Connes similarly argues that quantum consciousness is like orchestration - with different spacetimes as different clefs of music instruments, all synchronized in phase (by the score being played on piano for example or the conductor). In fact the music model is NOT WESTERN and so the harmonics and listening process resonates into ultrasound (called the Hypersonic Effect in nonwestern natural harmonics tuning, like Gamelan music) and infrasound - and the so-called 70 plus octaves of quantum time-frequency energy.

So the quantum measurement again assumes the left-brain dominance of science and yet this new force has to be acknowledged. As Professor Hiley emphasizes, most quantum physicists still try to ignore the truth of this real novel "self" or quantum force of reality. The quantum physics professor who taught me entanglement, in my first year of college, the same teacher of Lee Smolin, has the model that quantum physicists are literally creating new spacetime realities from this measurement collapse. His model though does utilize noncommutative phase - for his new entanglement signals to be tested as satellite communication.

So the assumption is that noncommutative time-frequency is a byproduct of this quantum self-force that itself creates both space and time from a timeless dimension. The debate is whether this assumes the measurement collapse with particles inherent to the eigenstates - as most models assume - or whether the quantum self-force intervenes as soon as the quantum physicist has the intention of making the measurement!

But as I have described - in fact there is reverse entropy to time as the noncommutative phase - and this is always-already ongoing as eternal natural resonance of reality. It's just that left-brain dominance cuts us off from this flow of time, and so quantum physicists have constructed 25 different models that really are a psychological projection of discovering this inherent limitation of science. As Bernard d'Espagnat emphasized, we can logically infer this underlying quantum self-force origin as consciousness despite the limitation of linear time causation in relativity.