Why Xenaxis was wrong about music math analysis

Wow - thanks so much Dr. Beaulieu! Xenaxis states, "I believe this to be a sign of Aristoxenos' wisdom; the ratio 3/4 could in fact be a mean value." p. 185. That is an amazing admission! Because in fact, as I've stated - it is this cover up of 2/3 subharmonic Perfect Fifth, doubled to 4/3 as the Perfect Fourth, that concealed the "noncommutative phase" that in fact is quantum and nonlocal as the infinite spiral of fifths (and the secret of the Tai Chi and the three gunas of India, etc).

Thank you for your astounding article as you have made this same connection between the quantum and spiral of fifths, and as I stated, math professor Alain Connes makes this explicit - and he is a "top" mathematician, with a Fields Medal. haha. But you are right - it is quite amazing, I remember your story about John Cage and your listening to your nerves. Turns out it's now proven that the highest pitch we hear externally - when listened to - resonates into ultrasound internally. This was discovered in tinnitus research - ultrasound beam focused on the brain demodulates to the highest pitch heard externally - but the reverse is true as the research states, it's easier to just use that highest pitch externally to resonate the brain as a whole. And the "Hypersonic Effect" research documented the natural harmonics of ultrasound then increase alpha brain waves as increased serotonin.

I actually performed John Cage in my senior high school piano recital with "prepared piano." My piano teacher married her University professor who had retired early as a local Twin Cities conductor and composer - and so then he taught me orchestration, ear training, music theory, sight reading and composition, privately. Then when I graduated, he gave me a copy of the Tao Te Ching and Gregory Bateson's book "Mind and Nature." My first year of college I took as my first physics course quantum mechanics. haha. So all those influences really made me ponder the deeper meaning of sound and resonance.

Actually it was after I had memorized Bach's Italian Concerto in high school - when I was at UW-Madison I was part of a paid science drug test and the nurse had to give me an EEG before I could be a part of the study. She exclaimed in shock at how strong my alpha waves were! This got me thinking about what could have caused that and I realized all my music training had altered my brain waves and then discovered the Mozart Effect is based on the slow middle movements of Baroque. The middle movement of Bach was always my favorite - one beat per second. I'm sure that is what did it as my piano teacher was shocked at how fast I memorized Bach - and so I'm sure I had gone into a trance for better visualization skills.

I discuss the Lyre as the Liar - in my "Alchemy of Rainbow Heart Music" pdf - free online. I mean - research shows how the lyre was used for right-brain memorization of vast information, by singing. Similarly dementia patients become lucid after hearing their favorite music. So now it's proven that left brain dominance will lie about the right brain truth perceptions (when the corpus callosum is cut) and also the left brain dominance cuts us off from our lower body emotional neurohormones. The right brain vagus nerve connects to the left brain but not vice versa! Pretty fascinating - since the left vagus nerve goes down to the heart, but the right side vagus nerve goes up from the reproductive organs.

Your Perfect Fifth article gives me better insight into the Pythagorean Logos meaning "creative fire" as alchemy - that I had cited in my master's thesis back in 2000. In Taoist Alchemy - you put the fire under the water - to build up the air as qi energy and so having the elements as part of the scale of Perfect Fifths, with the fire on top - fits with the alchemy training. But since fire is spirit - that is what guides the energy - and so you then have fire at the center as the heart. Alchemically originally the heart was also the earth organ - but as you state it is the fifth element that transcends the four - and this is the formless awareness. So your article is excellent!

I'm listening to your modal music as I type. There are tons of youtube vids on music meditation - and so I read the comments as people ask questions, but the people posting the vids often don't answer the questions. haha. So then I post my pdf as an answer as people looking to open their third eye from music binaural beats, etc.

And your nitric oxide paper was cited 37 times and so I looked over the other citations as well. What fascinates me about your research is stating that the sound can bypass the amgydala-limbic brain, and so my guess is since the vagus nerve is so close to the inner ear, this directly affects the autonomic nervous system, without the subconscious inhibitions, as anyone who gets immediate chills from music would realize. Also I think this is, as Dr. Mae-Wan Ho emphasized, due to phase stereophonic perception being faster than quantum time-frequency uncertainty. So that nonlinear amplification as listening - then creates nonlocal quantum synchronization as nonlocal consciousness. There is new research showing that when listening is faster than Fourier Uncertainty - this listening changes the "home" tone into a perfect fifth difference! So that is another quantum connection, as that study states. I should contact those authors about the noncommutative phase as Perfect Fifth!

In the Taoist alchemy training - the left ear is Yuan Qi. Why? Because the left ear activates the right side vagus nerve that is unmyelinated, and sublimates the lower neurohormones (the reproductive neurohormones) to the right side of the heart - for the deep "freeze" (samadhi, trance) theta brain waves, waking REM state. This is what Ramana Maharshi taught as well - the right side of the heart is the secret "pin hole" to formless awareness of the Universe (beyond death) - and the original human culture, the Bushmen San - they literally transcend physical death of their hearts stopping (as did Ramana Maharshi and my own teacher, Chunyi Lin). So the Yuan Qi originates fromm the right side of the heart and the yuan qi is also the formless awareness of the Universe.

That is why Ramana Maharshi said Mouna Samadhi is the highest level of samadhi - "silence" samadhi - you can't see the formless awareness but can listen to it.

I sit in full lotus as I listen to the music. Thanks.

Also your description of Kepler's music of the sphere analysis was the most straightforward I've read - simple and clear. Thanks!

Listening to your Debussy improvisation - I heard Suite Bergamasque that I used to perform. haha. Just a hint of it.

That's great - have you heard Dr. Bradford Keeney? He was a psychologist professor but studied shamanism world wide since as a religious jazz pianist he had this kundalini enlightenment experience, as a young college student. So now he focuses on the Bushmen healing - He does Jazz improv healing sessions.

 http://sacredecstatics.com/blog/

his music healing blog with some fascinating articles.

Have fun at your presentations.

Thanks again,

Dear Dr. Marcin Majka: Thank you for your follow up study on human hearing beating Fourier Uncertainty. I found the Perfect Fifth shift in home tone to be fascinating. (I did the test as well so could hear this shift).

Did you realize that in fact the Perfect Fifth is from noncommutative phase that is nonlocal? Math professor Alain Connes states this empirical truth of music harmonics means, as (2, 3, infinity) it is a "universal scaling system" that unifies quantum and general relativity. So math professor Luigi Borzacchini in his 2007 published article on incommensurabilty, the continuum and music theory - states that the concealment of music theory as the origin of Western math is "really astonishing" and "shocking" and that the subsequent symmetric math created as irrational magnitude is a "deep pre-established disharmony" that is the "evolutive principle" guiding Western science.

So for Archtyas, the collaborator of Plato, the Perfect Fifth as subharmonic 2/3, C to F had to be concealed, as the empirical truth - instead doubled to 4/3 C to F as Perfect Fourth. Why? Because Archytas was relying on the equation (arithmetic mean x harmonic mean = geometric mean squared) to create irrational magnitude as alogon. Therefore the truth of noncommutative phase that is quantum entanglement - in two places at the same time - this got covered up. In other words 2/3 as C to F subharmonic Perfect Fifth is also 3/2 as C to G overtone harmonic Perfect Fifth - the home tone shifts - but the phase is noncommutative as eternal resonance of time-frequency energy.

As you state, this Perfect Fifth bypassing time-frequency uncertainty reveals the quantum connection. Did you know that it's now proven that ultrasound resonates the microtubules of the brain as a whole to access quantum consciousness? So ultrasound demodulates as the highest pitch heard externally but the reverse works as well. If you listen to the highest frequency heard externally it resonates the whole brain as ultrasound, thereby resonating quantum proto-consciousness of the Universe as well. This is based on solid research from Stuart Hameroff and his colleagues.

This was known in nonwestern alchemy training - in China it is called the infinite spiral of fifths as the secret of Taoism, again as complementary opposites. Yang is Perfect Fifth and yin is perfect fourth. In India this is the secret of the "three gunas" the foundation of yoga training - the Octave is sattva, Perfect fifth is raga and Perfect Fourth is tamas. Again this is explained as noncommutative phase as complementary opposites that are nonlocal consciousness.

I have more details - I did my master's degree on "sound-current nondualism" in 2000 at U of MN but I still had the math wrong. So then I had to keep studying to figure out this cover up of noncommutative phase - but this secret was first rediscovered when Louis de Broglie analyzed Einstein's relativity, realizing that if time slows down as frequency increases to the speed of light, this violates the principle of Pythagoras that time is inverse to frequency. So then he deduced there are two time clocks, with Phase Harmony as a superluminal signal from the future.

This is now being accepted again, by some quantum physicists - for example when time is "zero" then there is quantum entanglement but since time-frequency is noncommutative then it is never zero. So there is a 5th dimension that is time-like as phase  and this phase shift is zero energy but eternal time. It was just proven experimentally - the time ring or time crystal has zero energy but has quantum spin as noncommutative phase! Of course left-brain dominance as language-based observation can not be time-frequency uncertainty - but stereophonic phase is quantum synchronized. So your Perfect Fifth discover has corroboration in the math.

thanks and please reply with any comments, etc.

I have my blog with more details - http://ecoechoinvasives.blogspot.com with my links to free articles, books, etc.

 Read former M.I.T. history professor on the elite control of science - David F. Noble, "The Religion of Technology" (1996) and "American by Design" - he got fired from M.I.T., as he proved in a lawsuit, for political reasons. He goes into the history of science in detail. He refused to use email also and was then professor in Canada at York U.

The standard ecology textbook by Odum was funded by the nuclear power industry! Ecology was ignored pretty much as a science until DNA was discovered, thereby ushering in patents, that Noble goes into in detail. So ecology is now taken over by Monsanto, Cargill, and other big business that has "captured" the EPA, FDA, USDA, USAID (CIA), etc.

I would like to hear Guy McPherson talk about this more in detail. I quoted an administrator at U of MN telling Monsanto - "for enough money will give you tomatoes as big as basketballs." For example my alma mater, U of MN, each year the Regents/President affirm an agreement with the federal government to promote agricultural exports as the former "Food for Peace" imperialism program - by wiping out local farmers, dumping oil-subsided grains, then those countries become dependent on U.S. "aid" as a tool in the cold war.

For example Somalian farmers controlled Mogadishu politically, until Cargill dumped grain at 1/6th the local price, wiping out the local farm prices, and Cargill, based in Minnesota, sponsors public t.v. and is promoted by our corporate newspaper Startribune. Cargill is the largest private corporation in the world but receives a huge amount of U.S. welfare - I exposed this in an op-ed https://homelessholocaust.wordpress.com/2012/12/27/profile-on-the-largest-private-corporation-cargill/
Cargill put in illegal soy storage elevators in the Amazon rainforest - and so supply side economics is how USAID and World Bank words - build the infrastructure and anyone burning the rainforest can get free money by selling soybeans to Cargill. Soybeans were even used as currency in the Amazon! Startribune did not even report that a Brazilian judge had ruled the soybean elevators illegal and Cargill did not care anyway as they had already put the elevators in.

These big business now control science - through the Universities, ever since it was made tax-deductible to "fund" science - I exposed 300 businesses at U of MN controlling research - Lawrence Soley got fired from U of MN after he had his research published on corporate control of Universities. But this goes back to their founding - for example Pillsbury took over the U of MN soon after its founding - Pillsbury was in Skull and Bones at Yale.

I remember studying conservation biology for a University semester in Costa Rica - School for Field Studies, 1992 - and the Tico (Costa Rican) economics professor (as part of our sustainability focus) said the best thing we could have done for ecology was not to fly to Costa Rica - not to use the fuel. Then a USAID speaker talked - I pointed out to him that USAID gives subsidies to promote export crops using monocultural pesticide, fertilizers, etc. He had no answer. The protected forest nearby was being hunted by the locals as they shared with me - obviously they are desperate for food - and so now Costa Rica pays locals to protect the forest more. But even Costa Rica considered a model, has serious problems.

So David F. Noble's last book goes back to the origins of Western civilization in the Levant and West Asia - on the "myth of progress" - the Promised Land is his book title. Excellent work. Noble was not afraid to be honest about civilization and science - he even exposed the Freemason origins of science and the misogyny of science out of Benedictine monks that Noble traced back to NeoPlatonic philosophy out of the 9th century. I traced this back to Plato and Archytas - mathematicians know this - a few - standard Western math is wrong, from the wrong music theory. It is actually quite fascinating - but as Guy McPherson points out, physics professor Albert Bartlett repeated this point over and over - it's very simple - Western civilization is based on the exponential math using technology for exponential increase in energy as economics with exponential increase in population. That wrong math is actually from the wrong music theory - going back to Plato and Archytas.